Fair Wear & Tear Guide

Understand what landlords can and can't charge you for. Fair wear and tear is your legal right — learn exactly what counts.

What Is Fair Wear & Tear?

Fair wear and tear is the normal deterioration that happens to a rental property just from everyday living. It's the natural result of someone actually living in the space—and it's your legal right.

Think of it this way: If you treat a place reasonably well and something wears out naturally over time, your landlord can't charge you to fix it. That's their responsibility as the property owner.

Every state in the US protects fair wear and tear. This isn't a suggestion—it's the law. Landlords cannot deduct from your security deposit for normal wear and tear, no matter what the lease says.

Fair Wear & Tear vs. Tenant Damage

Fair Wear & Tear

  • Scuff marks on walls from furniture or daily movement
  • Faded paint after 5+ years of exposure to light
  • Carpet flattening in high-traffic walkways
  • Small nail holes from hanging pictures
  • Worn door handles from regular use
  • Minor marks on countertops from everyday use
  • Sun-faded curtains or window coverings

Tenant Damage

  • Large holes in walls from impacts or removed fixtures
  • Burns, stains, or damage to carpet
  • Damage from pets (claw marks, urine stains)
  • Broken or cracked windows
  • Stains from spills that weren't cleaned promptly
  • Missing or removed fixtures and hardware
  • Graffiti or deliberate marks on surfaces

The key difference: Fair wear and tear happens naturally. Damage is caused by neglect or accidents.

The Age Factor Matters

Here's something critical that landlords often ignore: the age of an item completely changes whether something counts as damage or fair wear and tear.

Example: Same scratch, different age

Scratch on 8-year-old carpet:

Almost certainly fair wear. That carpet is nearing the end of its natural lifespan. A small scratch is normal deterioration.

Same scratch on 6-month-old carpet:

Possibly tenant damage. That carpet should still be in nearly perfect condition—this scratch might indicate misuse.

Most items have an expected lifespan. Paint typically lasts 3–5 years. Carpet usually 5–7 years. Appliances can last 10+ years. Once something reaches the natural end of its lifespan, repairs or replacement are the landlord's responsibility—not yours.

State-Specific Rules

While every state protects fair wear and tear, the exact definitions vary slightly. Some states have specific dollar amounts or deduction limits. Others define it differently for different types of damage.

For detailed information about your specific state's rules, security deposit timelines, and deduction limits:

Check Your State's Rules →

Ready to check your claim?

Now that you know what fair wear and tear is, let's figure out what your landlord can and can't charge you for.

Check My Deductions — Free